| "An omnipotent god who creates a world like ours isn't to be praised. It's to be blamed, for they cast the vast majority into endless torment and suffering on a whim. Anyone who would do such a thing isn't worthy of our obedience. They're worthy only of our pity." |
And an omnipotent God that imposed peace and justice would be a bully. You believe the Christian fundamentalist view of God to be bogus, but honestly when I read this I see you taking a lot of what they are saying as a given, and then judging God because of it. I see that a lot in Atheist dogma, too.
It makes it easy, because it offers a limited set of arguments to address. Expand that to the major religions, it gets more exhaustive. Expand it to all religions and you have to make a lifestyle out of opposing a being you don't believe in. In the end you are just arguing against people's OPINIONS of God, though, not God.
Take it one step further, and you find that everything in the argument falls apart. What if no one is right? What if it is all theory, no different than our limited understanding of everything else in the universe? What if all this religious nonsense has just paralleled our slow march toward scientific understanding?
In that case, we'd be the same as people who would stand today and brush off modern medicine because they once bled people to death. It is sad that most religion locked itself from advancing, but that is political, a means to power and authority, not the nature of personal faith or God. We've seen the same thing IN science, actually, when the ivory tower folks don't want their bogus theories questioned.
Instead of the conclusion I quote above, wouldn't it be just as easy to say that an omnipotent God that would create such a world must not be what they claim He is? Our sense of fairness, justice, even horror is based upon what we see with our limited senses, and then translated through our limited understanding.
A child that sees a lion eat a baby gazelle might make the same conclusion about God, and then happily go wolf down a hamburger without giving it much thought. We don't even understand the physical systems we live in, much less their moral implications in a universal sense. Our ignorance is huge enough to house God.